A franchise lets you run your own business without building everything from scratch. For many Calgary and Alberta entrepreneurs, it is an attractive way to become a business owner.
Key benefits include:
- An established brand that customers already recognize and trust.
- A proven system of products, procedures and pricing.
- Training and ongoing support from the franchisor.
- Group purchasing power with suppliers.
- System-wide marketing funded by the network.
- Better access to financing, since lenders often prefer known brands.
When the relationship works, both the franchisor and the franchisee benefit from each other's success.
The Risks of a Franchise Agreement
The same features that make a franchise attractive also create serious risks for the franchisee.
One-sided contracts. Franchise agreements are drafted by the franchisor and are rarely negotiable. They usually give the franchisor wide control over pricing, promotions, suppliers, renovations, renewal, termination and step-in rights. Franchisees typically receive very few rights in return.
Personal guarantees. Most franchisors require the owners to personally guarantee the franchise company's obligations. If the franchisor sues, your personal assets, including your home and savings, may be exposed.
Loans that survive the business. Money borrowed to buy the franchise, buy equipment or renovate the premises must still be repaid even if the franchisor terminates the agreement or takes over the location. Improvements made to leased premises are also often left behind for the landlord. A franchisee can lose the business and still be left with the debt.
Arbitrary Actions Franchisors May Take
Our civil litigation lawyers at OP Lawyers LLP see franchisors use their contractual powers in ways that can destroy a franchisee's business. Common examples include:
- Termination on thin or manufactured grounds. Minor, disputed or selectively enforced defaults are used to justify ending the franchise, sometimes after inspections or audits used as leverage.
- Step-in and takeover. The franchisor uses step-in rights to take control of the location, often a profitable one, and run it for its own benefit.
- Predatory promotions. The franchisor mandates deep discounts or "buy one, get one free" campaigns that push the store below cost, then issues default notices when the franchisee objects or cannot keep up.
- Retaliation. Termination or non-renewal threats follow a franchisee's complaint, refusal to sign a release, or effort to organize with other franchisees.
Alberta's Franchises Act requires both parties to deal fairly in performing and enforcing the franchise agreement. Courts have also recognized that unrestrained franchisor powers can lead to oppressive consequences for franchisees.
When an Injunction May Be Necessary
A lawsuit for damages can take years. If the franchisor terminates the agreement or takes over the store in the meantime, there may be no business left to save by the time the case is decided. Customers, staff, goodwill and the location itself can be lost permanently.
In those situations, a franchisee may need an interlocutory injunction: a court order that stops the franchisor from terminating or taking over the business until the dispute is resolved at trial.
The Law of Injunctions in Alberta
Alberta courts apply the three-part test from the Supreme Court of Canada's decision in RJR-MacDonald Inc. v. Canada (Attorney General), [1994] 1 SCR 311. The franchisee must show:
- A serious issue to be tried. The claim, for example that the franchisor breached its duty of fair dealing or good faith, is not frivolous or vexatious.
- Irreparable harm. Without the injunction, the franchisee will suffer harm that cannot be fixed by money damages later.
- Balance of convenience. The harm to the franchisee if the injunction is refused outweighs the harm to the franchisor if it is granted.
The second and third parts are often closely linked, and courts may consider them together.
Prohibitory versus mandatory orders
How the order is framed matters. An order that simply stops the franchisor from doing something, such as terminating the agreement or stepping in, is prohibitory and preserves the status quo. The franchisee only needs to show a serious issue.
An order that forces the franchisor to take positive steps, such as restoring system access or continuing to provide services, may be mandatory in substance. In that case, the franchisee must meet a higher bar and show a strong prima facie case, meaning a strong likelihood of success at trial.
When Could a Franchisee Obtain an Injunction?
Every case depends on its facts, but a franchisee's chances are strongest when three things line up: a fair-dealing complaint with real substance, a clean record, and a request that only preserves the status quo.
Situations where an injunction may be available include:
- Termination after a disputed promotion. The franchisor imposed a below-cost promotion, the franchisee complied under protest and documented its losses, and the franchisor now threatens termination for raising objections. The franchisee asks the court only to stop the termination until trial.
- Takeover of a profitable location on a technicality. The franchisor relies on a minor or already-cured default to exercise step-in rights over a successful store, while overlooking the same issue at other locations.
- Retaliatory termination. Termination follows shortly after the franchisee complained about the franchisor's conduct or refused to sign a release, and the franchisee is otherwise in good standing.
- Termination that would end the business entirely. The franchisee operates a single location, has no other income, and losing the franchise would effectively mean the "death" of the business. Alberta appellate authority recognizes this as a classic form of irreparable harm.
By contrast, an injunction is much harder to get where the franchisee has its own serious or incurable defaults, such as unpaid royalties, unauthorized products or dishonest conduct, or where the only loss is reduced profit that can be calculated later.
The Evidence a Franchisee Should Be Ready to Show the Court
Injunctions are won or lost on evidence. Alberta courts do not require full expert economic reports at this early stage, but they do require enough concrete evidence to support reasonable conclusions rather than speculation.
A franchisee should be prepared to provide:
- Financial records showing the business's revenue, costs and margins, and how the franchisor's conduct has affected them.
- Evidence the harm cannot be fixed with money: that termination would close the business, not just reduce profits, along with the loss of goodwill, customers, staff, lease and reputation.
- Evidence of the franchisor's conduct: notices, emails, directives, inspection reports and anything showing selective enforcement, retaliation or a refusal to consider the franchisee's concerns.
- Proof of the franchisee's own compliance: royalties paid, reports filed, brand standards followed, and any alleged defaults cured or disputed in writing.
- Personal exposure: personal guarantees, loans and leases that will remain owing if the business is lost.
- Answers to the franchisor's concerns on the balance of convenience, such as a commitment to keep meeting brand standards, continue paying fees, or pay money into court or trust to address collection risk.
Franchisees should also be prepared to give an undertaking as to damages, a promise to compensate the franchisor if the injunction later turns out to have been wrongly granted.
How OP Lawyers Can Help
When a franchisor threatens termination or takeover, time is critical. The civil litigation lawyers at OP Lawyers LLP in Calgary can:
- Assess your case quickly, reviewing your franchise agreement, notices and records to determine whether you have a serious claim and whether an injunction is realistic.
- Respond to default and termination notices within the contractual deadlines, protecting your rights and avoiding steps that could weaken your position.
- Build the evidence, including affidavits and financial records that show irreparable harm and address the franchisor's concerns.
- Frame the right order, seeking relief that preserves the status quo rather than a mandatory order that faces a higher legal bar.
- Bring the injunction application in the Court of King's Bench of Alberta and pursue your underlying claim.
- Negotiate a resolution. An injunction application often brings the franchisor to the table, and we have helped franchisees reach settlements on fair terms.
If your franchisor is threatening your business, contact OP Lawyers LLP to speak with a franchise dispute lawyer in Calgary.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is an injunction in a franchise dispute?
It is a court order that stops a franchisor from taking a step, usually terminating the franchise agreement or taking over the business, until the court decides the dispute. Its purpose is to preserve the business so there is still something to protect when the case is resolved.
How quickly can I get an injunction?
In urgent cases, an application can be brought within days, and a short-term order may be available while a full hearing is scheduled. Delay can hurt your case, so contact a lawyer as soon as you receive a termination or step-in notice.
Can I get an injunction if I have also breached the franchise agreement?
It is much harder. Courts look closely at the franchisee's own conduct. Serious or incurable defaults, such as dishonesty or selling unauthorized products, can defeat the application. Minor defaults that have been cured or are genuinely disputed are less likely to be fatal.
Is losing profits enough to show irreparable harm?
Usually not. If the loss can be calculated and paid as damages later, courts generally will not grant an injunction. The strongest cases show that termination would effectively end the business or cause losses, such as goodwill and reputation, that money cannot properly measure.
What happens if the court grants the injunction and I later lose at trial?
You will usually be required to give an undertaking to pay the franchisor's damages caused by the injunction if it turns out to be unjustified. Because owners often give personal guarantees, this risk should be discussed with a lawyer before applying.
Disclaimer: This blog post is intended for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. For advice specific to your circumstances, please consult a qualified Calgary civil litigation lawyer at OP Lawyers LLP or another legal professional.
