Parents often help their adult children financially. They contribute to a down payment, add a child’s name to a bank account, transfer an investment account, or put a child on title to a property. While everyone gets along, nobody asks what the money really was for. That question usually comes up at the worst possible time: when the child separates from their spouse or partner, or when the parent passes away and siblings disagree about the estate.
The leading case on this issue is the Supreme Court of Canada’s decision in Pecore v Pecore, 2007 SCC 17. It sets out how courts decide whether a transfer from a parent to an adult child was a true gift, or whether the child simply holds the property in trust for the parent. At OP Lawyers LLP, our Calgary family lawyers regularly see these issues arise in separation and property division, and early advice can make a significant difference to the outcome.
Key Takeaways
- When a parent transfers money or property to an adult child for nothing in return, the law presumes the child holds it in trust for the parent. This is called the presumption of resulting trust.
- The person claiming the transfer was a gift has to prove it on a balance of probabilities.
- The presumption of advancement, which presumes a gift, now applies only to transfers from parents (mothers or fathers) to minor children.
- Courts look for evidence of what the parent actually intended at the time of the transfer, including bank documents, wills, powers of attorney, tax treatment and statements made to others.
- These rules matter in family property division in Alberta, because a gift to one spouse is treated very differently from money held in trust for a parent or a loan that has to be repaid.
The Facts in Pecore v Pecore
Paula Pecore’s father was getting older and placed the bulk of his assets, almost $1 million in bank and investment accounts, into joint accounts with Paula, with a right of survivorship. Paula was the closest to him of his three adult children and, unlike her sisters, was not financially secure. She worked low-paying jobs and cared for her husband, Michael, who was quadriplegic. Her father had helped the family financially for years.
Her father alone deposited money into the accounts, continued to manage them, and paid all the tax on the income they earned. He also wrote to the financial institutions stating that the funds were not being gifted to Paula, in order to avoid triggering capital gains tax. His will left specific gifts to Paula, Michael and their children, and divided the residue of his estate equally between Paula and Michael. The will did not mention the joint accounts.
When her father died in 1998, Paula took the balance of the accounts as the surviving joint account holder. Paula and Michael later divorced. In their matrimonial property proceedings, Michael argued that Paula held the accounts in trust for her father’s estate. If he was right, the money would fall into the residue of the estate, and Michael would be entitled to half of it under the will.
The trial judge and the Ontario Court of Appeal both found that the father intended Paula to receive the accounts. The Supreme Court of Canada dismissed Michael’s appeal.
The Two Presumptions: Resulting Trust and Advancement
A “gratuitous transfer” is a transfer of property for which the recipient gives nothing in return. Because people rarely leave clear evidence of their intentions, and the person who made the transfer has often passed away by the time a dispute arises, the law uses two presumptions to fill the gap.
The presumption of resulting trust is the general rule. Equity presumes bargains, not gifts. So where one person transfers property to another for nothing, the law presumes the recipient holds it in trust for the person who transferred it, and the recipient must prove that a gift was intended.
The presumption of advancement is the exception. In certain relationships, the law presumes the opposite: that a gift was intended. The person challenging the transfer must then prove it was not a gift.
Either presumption can be rebutted. The Supreme Court confirmed that the ordinary civil standard applies: the evidence must show the parent’s actual intention on a balance of probabilities. The presumption only decides the case where the evidence is not strong enough either way.
Adult Children: No Presumption of a Gift
The most important part of Pecore is its answer to who the presumption of advancement applies to. The Court held that:
- It applies equally to mothers and fathers. Historically, the presumption only applied to transfers from fathers. The Court found that mothers today have both the means and the legal obligation to support their children, so they should be treated the same way.
- It applies only to minor children. The main reason for the presumption is a parent’s obligation to support dependent children. That obligation generally ends when a child becomes an adult.
- It does not apply to adult children, even if they are financially dependent. The Court found that “dependency” is too uncertain a test and would make outcomes unpredictable. However, evidence of an adult child’s dependency on the parent can still be strong evidence that a gift was intended.
The Court also recognized a practical reality: it is common for ageing parents to add an adult child to their accounts so the child can help manage their finances. That is not the same thing as intending to give the money away. The presumption of resulting trust reflects that reality.
In Pecore, the trial judge had wrongly applied the presumption of advancement, because Paula was an adult. However, the error made no difference, because the evidence clearly showed that her father intended her to receive the balance of the accounts on his death.
What Evidence Do Courts Consider?
The Supreme Court said the court must start with the correct presumption and then weigh all the evidence about the parent’s intention at the time of the transfer. Relevant evidence can include:
- Bank and account documents. Older cases treated these as relevant only to legal ownership. Pecore held that clear wording in modern banking documents, such as a right of survivorship, can be strong evidence of intention.
- Evidence after the transfer. Later statements and conduct are not automatically excluded, as long as they shed light on the parent’s intention at the time of the transfer. Courts are cautious with self-serving statements or evidence that only shows a later change of mind.
- Control and use of the funds. A parent who continues to manage and use the account may suggest a trust, but this is not decisive. A parent can give a child the right of survivorship while still controlling the account during their lifetime.
- Powers of attorney. If the parent only wanted help managing their money, a power of attorney might have been enough. Giving both a power of attorney and joint ownership may suggest something more was intended, although this is not determinative either.
- Tax treatment. Who paid the tax on the income is relevant, but not determinative on its own.
- The relationship. The closeness of the relationship and the child’s financial circumstances can be considered in deciding whether the presumption has been rebutted.
In Pecore, the deciding evidence included the father’s close relationship with Paula, his statements that he would take care of her after his death, and the testimony of the lawyer who drafted his will. The father had not mentioned the joint accounts when the lawyer asked about assets that would pass outside the will. The court accepted that he believed those accounts had already been dealt with.
Why Pecore Matters in Alberta Family Law
Although Pecore was an Ontario case, it is a Supreme Court of Canada decision and is applied by courts across the country, including in Alberta. For separating spouses and adult interdependent partners in Calgary, it often comes up in property division under the Family Property Act. Common examples include:
- Help with a down payment. Parents contribute money towards the purchase of a home. After separation, one partner says it was a gift to the couple, while the other says it was a gift to them alone, a loan from their parents, or money held in trust for the parents.
- Joint accounts with a parent. One spouse holds a joint bank or investment account with their parent. The other spouse argues the account is family property, or that it really belongs to the parent or the parent’s estate.
- Inheritances and estate disputes. As in Pecore itself, a separation can trigger a dispute over assets that passed outside a parent’s will.
The answer matters because the Family Property Act generally exempts gifts and inheritances that one partner receives from a third party, such as a parent, from equal division. Money that was a loan, or that is held in trust for a parent, is treated differently again. The characterization of a single transfer can change the property division result by tens or hundreds of thousands of dollars.
Alberta courts continue to apply Pecore strictly. In Ferguson Estate (Re), 2025 ABCA 94, the Alberta Court of Appeal upheld a finding that a daughter had not proven her mother gifted her shares in a family corporation, despite their close relationship. There was no deed of gift, and the daughter had not reported the income she would have received if the shares had been hers.
Practical Tips for Parents and Adult Children
- Put it in writing at the time. A signed gift letter, loan agreement or declaration of trust made when the money is transferred is the best evidence of intention.
- Be clear about who the gift is for. If parents want to give money to their child alone and not to the child’s spouse or partner, the documents should say so.
- Make sure your will and your accounts match. Joint accounts with a right of survivorship can pass outside a will. Speak with your lawyer about how these accounts fit with your estate plan.
- Consider a pre-nuptial or cohabitation agreement. Where significant family money is involved, an agreement can set out how gifts and inheritances will be treated if the relationship ends.
- Keep records. Bank statements, emails and messages from the time of the transfer can become important evidence years later.
How OP Lawyers LLP Can Help
Disputes about family money are often emotional and can involve parents, siblings and in-laws as well as the separating couple. The outcome usually depends on the evidence available, so it is important to get advice early.
At OP Lawyers LLP, our Calgary family lawyers can help you:
- Understand how gifts, loans and inheritances from family are treated under the Family Property Act
- Assess whether a transfer from a parent is likely to be treated as a gift, a loan or a resulting trust
- Gather and present evidence of intention, including documents, banking records and witness evidence
- Negotiate a fair property division or represent you in the Court of King’s Bench
- Prepare pre-nuptial, cohabitation and separation agreements that deal clearly with family gifts and inheritances
If you are separating and money from your family or your partner’s family is part of the picture, contact OP Lawyers LLP to book a consultation with an experienced Calgary family lawyer.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is money from my parents a gift or a loan in Alberta?
It depends on what your parents intended at the time. If you are an adult and your parents gave you money for nothing in return, the law presumes you hold it in trust for them unless you can prove they intended a gift. Written documents from the time of the transfer are the best evidence.
Are gifts from my parents divided when I separate in Alberta?
Under the Family Property Act, gifts from a third party, such as a parent, to one spouse or partner are generally exempt from division. However, you must prove the money was a gift to you alone, and the outcome can be more complicated if the money was used to buy a home held in both names.
If my parent adds me to their bank account, do I own the money when they die?
Not automatically. Under Pecore v Pecore, you are presumed to hold the account in trust for your parent’s estate unless there is evidence that your parent intended you to receive the balance through the right of survivorship.
Does Pecore v Pecore apply to both mothers and fathers?
Yes. The Supreme Court held that the presumption of advancement applies equally to mothers and fathers, but only for transfers to minor children.
Disclaimer: This blog post is intended for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. For advice specific to your circumstances, please consult a qualified Calgary family lawyer at OP Lawyers LLP or another legal professional.
